Update on Heart Monitor Frustration

Wednesday, February 04, 2015

First of all thank you for the suggestions. JazzID, I ordered the electrode gel that you suggested and let me say, BRILLIANT, but even with that the 00's persisted on my F11 so I bought the Polar FT4.

To compare accuracy between it and my F11, I put one on each wrist, did a workout and they BOTH worked perfectly. Identical heart rate readings throughout, even during the HIIT sections which is where it would usually tap out. So, conclusion? It was the sensor or the strap that was defective, not the watch!! You see, for the test, I used the strap and sensor that came with the FT4 instead of my old one and all of a sudden, my old F11 was reborn!

So, did I keep the FT4 considering that it only cost $10 more than a new strap and sensor by itself (interesting)? No. Why? Because I didn't realize it when I ordered it but it doesn't have all the bells and whistles that my F11 has (training program, diary etc) and my F11's Solar Link no longer works so I'm not able to transfer my workouts to the computer so I sent it back to get a more functional one.

As I researched the new Polar watches however, I realized, much to my annoyance that although they have watches with tech similar to my F11, you now have to buy an additional accessories to transfer your data to the site.

The Polar Flow Link will connect to your PC and transfer directly from your watch (approx $45 on Amazon) OR you can download the free Polar Beat app which will transfer it automatically but you need to purchase a H7 Bluetooth Heart Rate Sensor for it to do so (approx $52 on Amazon). Grrrrrr emoticon .

So, I ended up getting the Polar FT60, the H7 Bluetooth HR Sensor and the Polar Beat App.

The Polar FT60 worked for a week then stopped reading my heart rate, the H7 Bluetooth sensor works PERFECTLY thus eliminating my need for a heart rate monitor at all!!!!!

You see, the H7 Sensor transmits not only to the HRM (watch) but to anything receivable around it like the Runkeeper (which Spark People links to, YAY) and/or Polar Beat iPhone app which so far it does almost flawlessly.

Now I not sure how accurate the calorie burn reading is because although the heart rates between my F11, Polar Beat and Runkeeper are identical during the workouts, they all conclude with different calorie burns (300, 350 and 495 respectively). Do I care that Runkeeper's read is so exaggerated? No. I don't mine being lied to when it makes me feel better. "No honey, you do NOT look fat in that dress" emoticon . And I don't eat my exercise calories (on purpose anyway) so it won't sabotage my weight loss efforts.

So, I returned the FT60 this morning and I am back to using my old F11 (which has worked wonderfully since I started using the new sensor and strap and the electrode gel) and with the iPhone apps, I can do everything the newer Polar watches purport to do (training programs, analyze and transfer workouts to computer), but DON'T, at least not for me. Maybe I'm too electric emoticon emoticon ?
Share This Post With Others
Member Comments About This Blog Post
    ... I don't know Sue... I tried new straps, batteries, and even bought a new unit the present F4, and still had problems until I bought that gel. So far I have used this new HR monitor/strap for almost a year and sometimes it will still read 00, but when I put more gel on it, it starts to pick up my HR.

    I don't remember having this problem with my first POLAR, can't remember which one, but they no longer make it and the strap/sensor was different, both ends detached from the front section of the strap.

    ... anyway, I hope you have solved the problem. I am going no further than what I am using now.... just too much!!! emoticon
    2246 days ago

    Comment edited on: 2/15/2015 8:38:20 PM
    Great job fixing the problem! Spark on!
    2256 days ago
    I'll have to check into the H7...sounds emoticon ... Thanks for the critique share. Gives me something to think about.

    Now go on with your ELECTRIC-self! emoticon ..Love it!

    2256 days ago
  • Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

    Log in to post a comment

    Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.

More Blogs by MELTNSUE